The Lebanese war · 111101 entry in the original chronology
Other date in the books: Monday, 13 January 1986
|
24 entries on 24 dates · the books disagree on 24
The Lebanese war · 111101 entry in the original chronology
Other date in the books: Monday, 13 January 1986
The Lebanese war · Added from the books
Sources differ: De Clerck and Malsagne link the killings to the break between Hezbollah and the Communist Party; Hanf attributes the murders of Communist intellectuals in early 1987 to Amal supporters. Neither names the killers of Mroue specifically.
The Lebanese war · Added from the books
Sources differ: Date: 22 February (Hanf; de Clerck and Malsagne, twice), 20 February (Picard), 28 February (Traboulsi). 22 February has the most support and is also the date given in original entry 988. Size of force: two brigades (Hanf), 12,000 soldiers plus Special Forces (de Clerck and Malsagne), 8,000 (Quéméner).
Other dates in the books: Friday, 20 February 1987, Saturday, 28 February 1987
The Lebanese war · Added from the books
Sources differ: Hanf places the killing of 23 Hezbollah fighters right after the Syrian entry of 22 February, and Fisk writes of Syrian killings of prisoners in Beirut in February 1987; de Clerck and Malsagne date the storming of Hezbollah's headquarters and the killing of about twenty members to the end of 1987. The Confluences article is by the same two authors, so it is not independent confirmation. February has the better support.
The Lebanese war · 111101 entry in the original chronology
Other date in the books: Sunday, 22 February 1987
The Lebanese war · 111101 entry in the original chronology
Other dates in the books: Friday, 11 September 1987, Monday, 18 January 1988
The Lebanese war · Added from the books
Sources differ: Hanf's footnote 220 dates the same Hottinger article to 6 May 1987, his bibliography to 6 April 1987.
The Lebanese war · Added from the books
Sources differ: Responsibility: Hanf names Amal supporters; de Clerck and Malsagne place the killing in the context of the Hezbollah-Communist break without naming the killers.
The Lebanese war · Added from the books
Sources differ: Hanf lists CGTL political strikes in 1987 for April, July, August, September and November, but none in June. The strike began four days after Karami's assassination, on the day Husseini resigned (original entry 1003).
The Lebanese war · Added from the books
Sources differ: End of the camps war or siege: 5 April 1987 ceasefire (de Clerck and Malsagne; original entry 989), 11 September 1987 (Picard), 18 January 1988 (Hanf), January 1988 for Chatila (de Clerck and Malsagne, who date the war 1985-1987).
Other dates in the books: Sunday, 5 April 1987, Monday, 18 January 1988
The Lebanese war · Added from the books
Sources differ: De Clerck and Malsagne date the start of the Amal-Hezbollah conflict to a Syrian assault on Hezbollah at the end of 1987, and its first phase to 5 April 1988.
The Lebanese war · Added from the books
Sources differ: Inflation for 1987: 620 percent retail prices (Hanf) against 450 percent for the Beirut consumer price index (de Clerck and Malsagne); the two measure different things. The original entries 979, 1011, 1033 and 1038 give the daily stages (about LL 100 in February, 162 in July, near 500 in late October).
After the war · From the books
Sources differ: Farewell ceremony 9 October 2002 versus replacement in December 2002.
Since 2005 · From the books
Sources differ: Death toll differs: 22 dead (de Clerck & Malsagne, p. 461 and p. 577); Hariri 'and eight companions' (Abirached, p. 243, although the same chronology's 7 April entry speaks of Hariri 'and twenty-two other persons'); 18 dead (Quéméner). The counts may cover different groups (convoy only, or all victims, including those who died later).
Since 2005 · From the books
Sources differ: Two contributors to the same volume differ: Abirached's chronology dates Karami's resignation to 28 February, Khayat's chapter to 27 February. Abirached's dated chronology is the more precise of the two.
Since 2005 · From the books
Sources differ: Crowd size: about 800,000 (Abirached; Khayat) against 400,000 (Quéméner). De Clerck & Malsagne call it the first mass demonstration, whereas Khayat places it the day after the opposition's third Monday rally.
Since 2005 · From the books
Sources differ: 7 May (Quéméner) or 8 May (Abirached). Each date has one source; the others give only 'May' or 'a few days after' the withdrawal.
Since 2005 · From the books range
Sources differ: The two chapters of the same book disagree on when voting ended: 12 June in Abirached's chronology, 19 June in Khayat's chapter. Picard dates the elections simply to May 2005.
Since 2005 · From the books
Sources differ: 2 June in four sources (de Clerck & Malsagne, Abirached, Quéméner, Khayat) against 1 June in Haugbolle. 2 June has the most support.
Since 2005 · From the books
Sources differ: Abirached's chronology has Siniora forming the government on 30 June; Khayat says only that he was designated at the end of June. For the government itself, de Clerck & Malsagne (Confluences) give 19 July (see the following entry).
Since 2005 · From the books
Sources differ: Most sources say July (Confluences 19 July, Picard July); Abirached's chronology has 30 June, perhaps Siniora's designation, which the same book's narrative puts at the end of June.
Since 2005 · From the books
Sources differ: 26 July (Abirached) and 'end of July' (Khayat) against 'June 2005' (de Clerck & Malsagne, p. 451-452). Haugbolle's source for the wife's words is al-Nahar of 18 July 2005, which may refer to the amnesty vote rather than the release.
Since 2005 · From the books
Sources differ: 1 September (Abirached) against end of August (Khayat; Picard gives August). Two sources favour late August.
Since 2005 · From the books
Sources differ: Picard has 31 October, Abirached 1 November; a late New York vote on the 31st would fall on the 1st in Beirut, but this is unchecked.